Why Netflix's batshit horror The Perfection doesn't make sense

-

Get Out's Allison Williams and Dear White People's Logan Browning star in Netflix's B movie Black Swan about rival cellists. Yet somehow it doesn't quite work.

The main problem is a common one for ambitious horror flicks – it tackles dark, very serious themes in a superficial way.

Cast your minds back to 2008's Teeth, another film with an interesting subtext that was tonally all over the place.

Most people agree Teeth is a black comedy, a body horror twist on a coming of age drama. Yet the plot sees the heroine Dawn repeatedly raped by pretty much every man she meets.

2008's Teeth sees heroine Dawn repeatedly raped... yet it's still a black comedy?

True, these men do get their comuppence. Dawn fortunately has a toothed vagina, so it's soon raining severed dicks. But there's something horribly grim about watching repeated scenes of sexual abuse not taken very seriously.

The Perfection needs to treat its characters with more respect in order to get away with tackling such heavy themes

The Perfection has similar issues (and also severs body parts with childlike glee). Like Teeth you have to admire its audacity, both in themes and storytelling. And it has two terrific central performances, but Williams and Browning are tasked with playing contradictory characters whose actions make zero sense.

The film trades mainly in intense body horror gore (which we're in no way knocking) and sharp left turn plot twists. The first major twist is totally spoiled by the trailer. The second is just a bit stupid.


Its themes are similar to 2016's Neon Demon and 2011's Black Swan – it features women pushed to ridiculously high standards, jeapordising their mental stability for the sake of success. Like those films, The Perfection is a lurid melodrama. Sex, gore and amateur psychology are its bread and butter.

In The Perfection, Charlotte and Lizzie are rival cellists who go to alarming lengths to best each other

Unlike those films (potential spoiler here), The Perfection deals head-on with institutionalised rape by men in positions of power and influence. But this is treated as another gotcha plot twist. And (bizarrely) results in another gear shift as the movie becomes a camp slasher (no more spoilers now).

So to recap we have a plot which defies logic, a relationship between the two central characters that strains credability, and B movie treatment of serious themes which you're only half-willing to let the film get away with.


Horror movies are expected to tackle dark themes and make us uncomfortable. The Perfection does both of those things. A bus ride early in the movie where Lizzie (Browning) starts to become seriously ill is a gruelling watch. The gore in the film's climax is both wince-inducing and laughably OTT.

Yet there's still a jarring note, a feeling that The Perfection needs to treat its characters with more respect in order to get away with tackling such heavy themes. While the film is clearly having fun with its crazy extremes and twisty storytelling, it's trafficking in real instances of sexual abuse by powerful men that have real life consequences.


We're conscious that the Twittersphere is against us here – most people seem blown away by the sheer bravado of The Perfection and it's hard not to be swept up in the sheer nastiness of it all. But its blend of silliness and seriousness just doesn't cut it for us.

Do you love your Netflix horror? In that case, you're bound to be excited by the second series of The Haunting of Hill House, but here's why it sounds like a terrible idea from what we know so far.
Fill your Twitter feed with witty horror banter. Follow us:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The four weirdest horror movie sex scenes

-
Image
Gratuitous sex scenes are a mainstay in most horror flicks, but some stick in the mind for their general WTF nature. Here are the four most bizarre scenes of intercourse, handpicked in four different categories. This list includes consensual encounters only, so there'll be no appearances from otherwise memorable scenes such as the Midsommar fertility ritual, the Evil Dead handsy tree branches or the various penile decapitations in Teeth . Weirdest Slasher Hookup We all know teens in slasher films exist to have sex and then be inventively killed. But which movie has the most out-there adolescent coupling? There can be only one answer: WINNER:  Madman (1981) - hot tub scene TP (Tony Fish) and Betsy (Gaylen Ross) are enjoying a bit of aquatic loving, unaware the murderous Madman Marz is on the prowl. The scene has distinct soft porn vibes - the song choice of Steve Horelick's 'I Don't Need Words'; the slo-mo undressing; and seemingly endless shots of the couple circl...
Read more

The significance of The Entity's 10 different forms in It Follows

-
Image
The It of It Follows   takes several different forms, and we're told early on it could appear as "someone you know or a stranger in a crowd". If you pay close attention, it seems like each form is chosen specifically to mess with Jay (Maika Monroe) , acting as a manifestation of subconscious anxieties. Director David Robert Mitchell explained to Vulture that when choosing the form of It - often referred to as The Entity - he "tried to just think about what was troubling to me in each of those situations". Mitchell noted in the same interview that many of the forms The Entity takes are more significant than we realise - it's just too far away to properly register for most viewers. Bearing this in mind, I've listed all of the main forms The Entity takes and teased out how they're significant to Jay's mental state at that point in the film. #1 - Naked woman in the car park (Ruby Harris) There's some debate over who thi...
Read more

Top 10 slasher kills - from Friday the 13th to Terrifier

-
Image
Slasher movies have been preoccupied with the most inventive ways to kill folks for decades. Here's ten of horror's most elaborate murders from artisans such as Jason Voorhees, Freddy Krueger and Art the Clown. The kills are ranked on originality, gore effects and just how much they make your stomach turn. There's also a bit of info on how the special effects team worked their magic. It hardly needs saying, but be advised there are some bloody images and video clips below. 10/ Caught in a cat flap - Scream (1997) Killer: Ghostface Victim: Tatum Riley (Rose McGowan) What goes down: Tatum is confronted by Ghostface while grabbing some beers from the garage. What she thinks is a prank escalates quickly as the masked killer pulls a knife. Tatum looks to have the upper hand as she batters a flailing Ghostface with fridge doors and beer bottles. Yet then she makes the ill advised decision to try and squeeze through a cat flap. Ghostface can't beli...
Read more